Best Mid-Priced Anguilla Restaurants

On a sad September day in 2005, our #1 Anguilla restaurant for burgers said "Au Revoir".

Yes, that tragic day did come... Le Bar, first discovered years before, closed up shop.

Tears were shed as we thought of all the good memories affectionately. But we refused to wallow in our own misery for too long.

The hunt for the next best Anguilla burger was on!

But which Anguilla restaurants to try?

We searched high, we searched low. We surveyed people living on Anguilla. The recurring advice?

"Try Ferry Boat Inn. Theirs is unbeatable."

Maybe. But could they come close to Didier's fine, herb-stuffed, 12-ounce burger? Being professionals on a critical mission, we couldn't get sentimental. Off we went!

We made our way down to Blowing Point village, past the colorful, Caribbean school, past the local grocery shop, and took a right just before reaching Anguilla Ferry, down Cul-De-Sac.

Soon we saw the rustic sign...

The Ferry Boat Inn

Car doors slammed behind us, as we gazed out at the picturesque little restaurant perched right on Blowing Point beach.

Visually, this place was already ahead of the game.

Ten out of ten for location!

We took a seat right by the edge of the deck, enjoying the trades and the sun.

We waited for our friend Claire Devener to join us.

We pretended to examine the menu. But who were we kidding?

We were not here for the dolphin sandwich.

Our stomachs were not craving the snapper salad, as tasty as it sounded.

We were on a mission. Burgers!

As our waitress brought us two diet Cokes, a Carib and a rum punch (guess who!), Claire made her entrance. "Make that two rum punches," she announced.

"Claire!"

Would she miss out on the potential-next-best-burger on Anguilla? Never!

She skipped the menu-scan, and we all cut straight to ordering 5 big, juicy burgers.

We chat and drank and chat and drank.

And then, suddenly, the moment of truth had arrived...

Five sensational-looking hamburgers lay before us.

The Ferry Boat Burger

The moment my teeth sank into the burger, I knew. My sister knew. My Mom knew. My Dad knew.

This was our new #1 burger in Anguilla.

It was charbroiled to perfection, with lettuce, tomatoes and onion, all on a fluffy, white bun.

You want bacon? They'll put it on there! Just ask.

All served up with tasty fries, something we always missed at Le Bar.

Le Bar will always hold a special place in my heart. It's not every day you find a burger seasoned by a french cook with fine herbs.

The Ferry Boat Inn, though, is definitely our new burger champ among Anguilla restaurants.

The Ferry Boat Inn is just one of many excellent, fairly priced restaurants...

More Mid-Priced Favorites

E's Oven
Searching for inexpensive Caribbean dining? Like more expensive local restaurants such as Koal Keel and Oliver's, E's Oven has mouth-watering food, but for half the price.

Ripples
My sister, Yuki, must be the world's #1 picky eater. But Ripples has reduced her to a pile of happy blubbering... The best fish & chips, spaghetti & meatballs, and other wonderful Anguilla dining, all served up with a huge helping of happiness.

Le Bistro At Malliouhana Resort
Looking for the best French fries on this British colony? We found them!

Picante
In the mood for Mexican? Yes, Mexican in Anguilla! You're in luck!

Roadwell Cafe
An excellent Anguilla breakfast, accompanied by butterflies.

Cap Juluca: A Tale Of Two Restaurants
*2009 Note: Kemia is now closed, but Pimms remains open
Can anyone beat the Arawak Inn's hold on our award for "best pizza on Anguilla?"

Tasty's: A Contender For Best Breakfast
I've said it once, and I'll say it again: Anguilla restaurants, in general, don't do breakfast well. But we've found another exception...

Deon's Overlook
*2009 Note: Temporarily Closed
More and more, Anguilla is learning out to make a mean breakfast. But if you want the best of the best? The place for omelets and pancakes and all the mouth-watering breakfast your heart desires? Look no further...

Bankie Banx's New Beach Bar
Bankie Banx's beloved beach bar, The Dune Preserve, has been extended! With a brighter dining area, and a bigger menu, this spot is without a doubt in my top favorite Anguilla restaurants.

A St. Martin Salad on Anguilla
One of the best parts of visiting St. Martin is the delectable French cuisine. But what happens when I can find my favorite French meal on Anguilla?

A St. Martin Style Bistro on Anguilla
From the same talented chefs and owners who brought you the first "St. Martin Salad on Anguilla", here is their next project. It is ideal for a delightful, daytime meal!

Anguilla Sandy Ground Restaurants
The Sandy Ground community is home to many beach bars, nightlife spots, and cheap restaurants that serve up delicious food. This fun spot is no exception!

Do you know where to find the best hot dog, crayfish or french fry on Anguilla? Click here to add it to our Anguilla guide to top eats!

You can indeed have great meals at moderate prices on Anguilla. Every visit to Anguilla finds several more of these gems.

So stay tuned for more reviews by our family and by visitors to anguilla-beaches.com.

Don't miss a review! Stay in touch by subscribing to Anguilla Beach Lovers e-zine.

Note: Ever wonder how we rank these restaurants? Click here to find out.

And that makes me wonder how do you rank restaurants? Do you agree or disagree with our family's opinion? What's your favorite? Click here to share it!